MEET OUR STAFF

Our Clergy

Rector

The Rev. Nathaniel S. Anderson was born in Boston and grew up in North Easton, Mass.. He earned a B.A. in philosophy from Luther College (Decorah, Iowa) in 2007 and an M.Div from Lutheran Theological Southern Seminary (Columbia, S.C.) in 2011. His fondest memories of seminary include playing flag football for the Southern Seminary “Flying Dove” – facing off against other Lutheran and Episcopal seminaries in the annual “Luther Bowl” tournament.

In 2018 Nathaniel was called to serve St. John’s as our ninth rector, having served as pastor and rector at Christ the King Lutheran Church and The Episcopal Church of the Epiphany, both in Wilbraham, Mass.

He was received into the Episcopal Church in 2019.

Nathaniel is married to college sweetheart Carolyn Starz, a biology teacher at Mount Greylock Regional High School in Williamstown, whom he met the first day of choir rehearsal sophomore year.

They are proud parents of James, stillborn in 2015, Inga born in 2017, and Bernadette in 2020. They love living in Williamstown, taking advantage of great hiking and renovating their home. Nathaniel and Carolyn enjoy what can only be described as “hipster farming,” along with running, hiking, cooking, and discovering delicious new beers.

At St. John’s Nathaniel loves to preach, teach, and walk with God’s people in this life of discipleship. You’ll often see him around town or on campus, and he’d love to have a cup of coffee and get to know you better. Contact Nathaniel here.

Curate

Misty Kiwak Jacobs is a native of Scottsdale, Arizona. She spent her college years in the Northeast, studying Russian, Writing and Literature at Sarah Lawrence College. While a student in Moscow, Russia in her early 20s, Misty felt the call to Christianity and was baptized. In 2015, a historic sign and red doors of a country church lured her into the Episcopal Church; the expansive welcome and the focus on God’s grace kept her here.

After raising her children and working as a freelance writer, Misty earned a Master of Divinity and a Diploma in Anglican Studies from Yale Divinity School in 2020. After graduation, she served as a Chaplain Resident at a Level I Trauma Center in 2020-2021, and earned a Sacred Theology Masters in Homiletics from YDS in 2023.

Misty has two children, Isaiah born in 1996 and Malachi born in 1999. Misty enjoys writing, rescuing dogs, rewatching Midsomer Murders and sharing meals with friends. The belief in God’s infinite mercy, and the healing power of mercy and love in community, define her call to ministry. Contact Misty here.

Primary Celebrant

Peter has roots in the Capital region of New York and is trained as a classroom teacher, school psychologist, and school leader. As a young adult, Peter was active in the ministries of the Metropolitan Community Church in San Francisco, CA. This is where he experienced God’s profound presence in liturgical worship.

Peter returned to the northeast, and while teaching Sunday School, he discerned the need to more deeply engage the scriptures and church history. Peter began attending Yale Divinity School in 2015. Shortly after beginning seminary he discovered that his attendance was more than academic; and he began to discern holy orders.

Peter earned a Master of Divinity degree from Yale Divinity School and a Diploma in Anglican Studies from Berkeley Divinity School in 2020. He found “home” in the Diocese of Western Massachusetts and served Trinity Episcopal Church, Lenox, MA as a seminarian, transitional deacon, and curate.

Peter and his husband Keith Feltman were married in 2000. They have three adolescent sons, Micah, Lucas, and Noah, and are grateful for both human and divine adoption. Peter is interested in ministries that build community, deepen our care for each other, and celebrate God’s presence in our everyday interactions.

We’re excited to welcome The Rev. Peter Feltman-Mahan as our primary celebrant on Sunday morning. Peter is a relatively recently ordained priest having spent the bulk of his professional career as an educator and school administrator.